Search
Contact
25.04.2019 | KPMG Law Insights

If university continuing education falls under the concept of aid in Art. 107 para. 1 TFEU?

Facts: In a case currently before the ECJ (C-393/17), two operators of a non-accredited private university in Belgium are seeking the annulment of the fines imposed on them. The reason for the criminal sanction payment is what the Flemish law enforcement agency considers to be the illegal awarding of academic titles.

Significance for state aid law: The facts of the case, which take place in criminal law, largely revolve around the concept of service and its applicability to state and private universities. The argumentation presented here by the Attorney General is, however, equally relevant with regard to the question of whether university offers for the further education of professionals, which are provided in return for payment, are to be regarded as economic activities within the meaning of state aid law.

The “Humbel Criteria”: According to Art. 57 TFEU, a service is a service rendered for remuneration, whereby this must be understood in the sense of an economic consideration for the service rendered. Despite the levying of a school fee, since the ECJ ruling Humbel and Edel (263/86), education is fundamentally not considered a service, since the state does not take up a profit-making activity within the national education system, but fulfills its social, cultural and educational duties. According to recent case law, this also applies to institutions of higher education in the state education system, insofar as these would be financed primarily from public funds, even if fees occasionally had to be paid to cover costs.

Expansion to private colleges: The Attorney General is challenging this assessment, which dates back to the 1980s. He argues that the sharp boundary of fee-for-service for public and private universities can no longer apply in today’s higher education landscape:

“What is governmental in a world where (even) state universities are setting up campuses in other member states or entering into joint ventures with various other institutions and/or creating spin-off companies for teaching and research?”

The image of the noble state university, exclusively concerned with the common good, versus the capitalist construct of the private university, is outdated, he said, as the former also charge fees for courses of study as well as (weekend) events for managers. There is a parallel with the health care system, which, although partly characterized by private providers, is classified as a non-economic service of general interest to which the freedom to provide services does not apply. Consequently, an exclusion of the general interest could not be assumed from the outset in the case of private education providers.

Therefore, it would have to be delineated as follows:

  • After each individual activity (especially each course of study).
  • By level of education, since only in primary and secondary education the social character of education is evident, but not in higher education
  • According to financing of the study program and the question of consideration, the following aspects play a role here:
  • Cost bearing (not exclusively and directly by the customer)
  • Market criterion (the larger the market for a program [national, European, global], the less it can be assumed that a special and unique social and cultural objective is pursued.

Significance for the practice of state aid law: If the ECJ were to follow the argumentation of the Attorney General, the example of the paid further training of professionals would probably constitute an economic activity due to the fact that the costs are borne by the customer, which would consequently have to be shown as such in the separation calculation. However, such a ruling would have an influence on further areas of university activity, so that the decision of the ECJ must be awaited here for the time being.

Explore #more

08.12.2023 | PR Publications

Payout can be risky

In the current issue of Personalwirtschaft from 30.11.2023, there is a guest article by Stefan Middendorf and Gracjan Modrzyk. Some companies are once again…

07.12.2023 | PR Publications

Institutional Money – It’s all in the mix

Institutional Money 04/2023 discusses the opportunities offered by the Neighborhood Fund. The fund is ideal for real estate investors, as it is not limited to

01.12.2023 | PR Publications

WiWo: Best of Legal Awards – Philipp Glock Leader of the Year

On Thursday evening, WirtschaftsWoche honored outstanding projects and minds from consulting firms and law firms in Düsseldorf and celebrated the second Best of Professional Night…

29.11.2023 | KPMG Law Insights

Energy transition also opens up business opportunities

The energy industry’s complex, capital-intensive transformation process offers investors and banks a great deal of potential By Lars Christian Mahler and Marc Goldberg for Börsen-Zeitung,…

29.11.2023 | KPMG Law Insights

Guest article in ZURe – AI and the legal department of tomorrow

The current issue of ZURe (p. 48 ff.) contains a guest article by KPMG Partner Sina Steidel-Küster (Regional Director Southwest, Head of Stuttgart office) and…

29.11.2023 | KPMG Law Insights, KPMG Law Insights

Key Facts about the new draft of the “Data Act

On February 23, 2022, the EU Commission presented the new draft of the so-called Data Act, the “Regulation on harmonized rules for fair access to…

21.11.2023 |

Guest article in ZURe on the implementation of CSRD reporting in SMEs

The current issue of ZURe (p. 34 ff.) contains a guest article by Lena Plato (Director Legal & Compliance, FLABEG Automotive Group GmbH), KPMG Law…

20.11.2023 | Press releases

Statement by KPMG Law experts in Handelsblatt on the topic of sustainability cooperation in antitrust law

In the Handelsblatt, KPMG Law expert Jonas Brueckner is quoted in detail on the subject of cooperation in terms of sustainability. Until this summer, there…

15.11.2023 |

Legal 500 – Country Comparative Guide Germany

Gerrit Rixen and Jonas Brueckner provide an overview of the relevant legal regulations in the area of Competition & Litigation in a practical guide on…

14.11.2023 | Press releases

Tax and Law at a glance – New issue of the digital magazine “Talk

“Talk” stands for Tax and Law Compass, because that’s what the digital magazine wants to be: a navigation aid to the legal and tax aspects…

© 2023 KPMG Law Rechtsanwaltsgesellschaft mbH, associated with KPMG AG Wirtschaftsprüfungsgesellschaft, a public limited company under German law and a member of the global KPMG organisation of independent member firms affiliated with KPMG International Limited, a Private English Company Limited by Guarantee. All rights reserved. For more details on the structure of KPMG’s global organisation, please visit https://home.kpmg/governance.

 KPMG International does not provide services to clients. No member firm is authorised to bind or contract KPMG International or any other member firm to any third party, just as KPMG International is not authorised to bind or contract any other member firm.

Scroll