Search
Contact
31.03.2020 | KPMG Law Insights

Company pension plans – Effects of the Corona crisis on pension obligations

Effects of the Corona crisis on pension obligations

The outbreak of the coronavirus has led to sharp falls in financial markets worldwide. The leading stock indices in the USA and Europe plummeted by more than 30%. There were also significant price falls on the bond markets. Employers must register short-time work. Economists expect a global recession. In this Client Alert, we would like to explain the main implications that the global Corona crisis may have for pension obligations under company pension plans, and also point out possible ways of reducing pension burdens under labor law.

1. significant influences on the occupational pension system
The world of work and business is significantly affected by the Corona crisis. This also applies to the companies’ pension obligations. Currently, this mainly relates to the decrease in the scope of obligations resulting from the increase in the actuarial interest rate. On the other hand, the slump in the stock markets is causing existing plan assets to shrink. How lasting these current effects will be ultimately depends on the temporal scope of the current shutdown. What long-term effects the Corona crisis will have on occupational pension schemes can only be speculated at present.

2. actuarial interest rate
The most significant factor influencing the gross pension obligation is the discount rate. According to the requirements of IAS 19, this is to be determined on the basis of yields on high-quality corporate bonds whose maturity and currency match the pension obligations. Yields on these fixed-rate corporate bonds have risen by around 70 basis points as a result of the Corona crisis. This was due to the price declines on the bond markets. Investors probably currently fear higher default risks even for good-quality corporate bonds. This rise in interest rates will lead to a significant decrease in pension obligations. Depending on the age structure of the pension beneficiaries, the decrease in the extent of the obligation can be up to 20%. However, it remains to be seen whether the interest rate increases will be sustainable. As in the times of the financial crisis, the ECB is trying with all its might to keep interest rates low and is once again expanding its bond-buying program.
Another threat to the actuarial interest rate comes from the rating agencies. If they also come to the conclusion that the default risks of companies previously rated good quality have increased due to the economic impact of the Corona outbreak, there could be downgrades in the corporate ratings. This is likely to lead to declines in interest rates under IAS19, as the returns of the graded companies can then no longer be used to determine interest rates. It therefore remains to be feared that the interest-related relief for corporate balance sheets is likely to be rather short-term. Yields on AA-rated bonds are currently extremely volatile and as of March 23, 2020, they have already fallen again somewhat. It remains to be seen how yields will change over the coming weeks. Under HGB, the discount rate is determined over a 10-year period. Short-term turbulence has only a marginal impact here.

3. plan assets
The declines on the global stock markets are also likely to have hit the numerous assets that have been segregated to fund the bAV. In the past, for example, numerous companies have begun transferring assets to a contractual trust arrangement (CTA) and using them to cover and fund pension obligations. CTAs currently manage assets worth almost EUR 300 billion for DAX 30 companies alone. These plan assets are recognized at fair value under both HGB and IAS19. Thus, even temporary volatilities are reflected in companies’ balance sheets. Whereas IFRS only requires these fluctuations to be recognized directly in equity, HGB even requires them to be recognized in the income statement. The extent to which plan assets are reduced also depends on the assets of which the plan is composed and the respective equity ratio.

4. mortality table
Due to the spread of the coronavirus, deaths are unfortunately to be expected. However, the mortality tables used to date should continue to be applied unchanged in the measurement of pension obligations. Extensive source material was collected to derive the mortality tables with the aim of reflecting long-term trends in mortality development in the mortality tables. Short-term, temporary events should have no influence on this.

5. contributions to insolvency insurance
The Pensionssicherungsverein (PSVaG) is the body responsible for statutory insolvency insurance for occupational pension schemes in Germany. In the event of a company’s insolvency, it takes over the provision of benefits for the beneficiaries protected by the insolvency proceedings. To finance it, the PSVaG sets a contribution rate each year. This contribution rate reflects the claims expenditure, i.e. the insolvencies of the respective calendar year. If there are increased bankruptcies due to the economic impact of the coronavirus, this could lead to an increase in the contribution rate for 2020. Currently, the contribution rate for 2019 is 3.1 per mille. In 2009, i.e. during the financial crisis, it amounted to 14.2 per thousand.

6. obligation of the companies to pay
Occupational pension plans are often no longer implemented directly by the employer by way of a direct commitment, but indirectly by (external) pension providers (direct insurance companies, pension funds, support funds and pension funds). Nevertheless, the employer is always liable within the scope of the statutory subsidiary liability. Some providers were already in financial distress before the Corona crisis due to the prolonged period of low interest rates. For example, the first reinsured provident funds were no longer able to finance regular pension adjustments in accordance with Section 16 of the German Company Pension Act (BetrAVG) from current surpluses. The situation was similar for some pension funds, some of which were no longer able to maintain high interest rate guarantees in their tariffs and even had to cut benefits.
If the funding situation of the pension providers were to deteriorate again in the long term as a result of the slump on the financial markets, further employer obligations to make contributions could become more likely and there is a risk of charges for additional contributions or additional contribution payments to the provider or the recognition of additional provisions in the company’s balance sheet if benefit differences have to be paid directly in the future.

7. labor law structuring means
Although it is essential for companies to maintain their liquidity in this crisis and, in particular, to reduce fixed costs such as personnel expenses, employer-funded pension contributions must (continue to) be made in accordance with the pension commitment, irrespective of the Corona crisis and any short-time working. In each individual case, it must be examined whether and to what extent the payment of short-time allowance affects the amount of the contribution. In the event of a deterioration in the economic situation, a modification of the commitment may be justified in accordance with the principles of labor law regarding the protection of legitimate expectations and the proportionality of the intervention.
In the context of employee-financed pension provision by means of deferred compensation, the employee can generally reduce or suspend his or her contributions if he or she adjusts the deferred compensation agreement accordingly and observes any existing deadlines. In this case, the employer’s mandatory or voluntary subsidies are also reduced or suspended. However, premium waivers or reductions also reduce benefits. In order to maintain the pension level as far as possible, a partial payment or a possible deferral of the contributions can be considered after agreement with the pension provider.

8. conclusion
It is difficult to predict today how lasting the effects of the Corona crisis on occupational pension schemes will be, and it will probably depend to a large extent on how long the pandemic and shutdown last. Hectic actionism is not advisable; especially in the area of companies’ longest-lived obligations – pension obligations – further developments should be monitored and a cost-saving concept tailored to the specific pension system should be developed. If the risk-bearing capacity of the occupational pension system has not been examined for some time, the current situation is a reason to do so.
We will be happy to support you and advise you on your current questions.

Explore #more

06.10.2025 | KPMG Law Insights

What the Green Claims Directive means for companies – an overview

With the Green Claims Directive, the EU will introduce extensive regulations on the requirements for permissible environmental claims. The aim is to prevent greenwashing so…

03.10.2025 | Deal Notifications

KPMG Law and KPMG support the restructuring of Groupe CAT in Germany

KPMG Law Rechtsanwaltsgesellschaft (KPMG Law) and KPMG AG Wirtschaftsprüfungsgesellschaft (KPMG) advised Groupe CAT on comprehensive restructuring measures with a cross-service team. Over a period of…

02.10.2025 | Deal Notifications

KPMG Law advises Epitype GmbH and MDG Molecular Diagnostics Group GmbH on the acquisition of significant assets of oncgnostics GmbH

KPMG Law Rechtsanwaltsgesellschaft mbH (KPMG Law) provided comprehensive legal advice to Epitype GmbH, a company of the Dresden-based MDG Group, on the formation and subsequent…

02.10.2025 | In the media

KPMG Law Statement in ZEIT for entrepreneurs: We’ll take the 500 billion!

German construction companies are asking themselves: how quickly will the money come from the government? And they are worried that only the giants will benefit.…

01.10.2025 | KPMG Law Insights

Federal Network Agency reforms special network charges for industry and commerce

The Federal Network Agency is planning a fundamental reform of the special network charges for energy-intensive companies. Any change to the current privilege regime entails…

30.09.2025 | In the media

KPMG Law dominates the top 100 list of the new law firm monitor with eight lawyers

KPMG Law Rechtsanwaltsgesellschaft mbH (KPMG Law) occupies an outstanding sixth place in the overall evaluation of the TOP 100 law firms in the current diruj…

29.09.2025 | KPMG Law Insights

MiSpeL draft: New funding for energy storage systems and charging points

On September 18, 2025, the Federal Network Agency published a draft for the “Market integration of storage systems and charging points” (MiSpeL for short). For…

29.09.2025 | KPMG Law Insights

Organizing the transformation and spin-off of corporate real estate with legal certainty

When real estate portfolios are to be transformed or spun off, the economic success depends heavily on the legal preparation. Complex legal issues often arise,…

25.09.2025 | KPMG Law Insights

MaGo update – roadmap for implementing the new requirements

On 14 July 2025, BaFin revised the circular “Minimum requirements for the business organization of insurance companies under Solvency II” (MaGo for SII-VU) and published…

25.09.2025 | KPMG Law Insights

Foundation register – launch to be postponed from 2026 to 2028

The reform of foundation law, which came into force in July 2023, created a nationwide foundation register based on the commercial register. This was actually

Contact

Dr. Julian Cahn

Manager

THE SQUAIRE Am Flughafen
60549 Frankfurt am Main

Tel.: +49 69 951195015
jcahn@kpmg-law.com

Christine Hansen

Senior Manager
Head of company pension scheme

Heidestraße 58
10557 Berlin

Tel.: +49 30 530199150
christinehansen@kpmg-law.com

© 2024 KPMG Law Rechtsanwaltsgesellschaft mbH, associated with KPMG AG Wirtschaftsprüfungsgesellschaft, a public limited company under German law and a member of the global KPMG organisation of independent member firms affiliated with KPMG International Limited, a Private English Company Limited by Guarantee. All rights reserved. For more details on the structure of KPMG’s global organisation, please visit https://home.kpmg/governance.

 KPMG International does not provide services to clients. No member firm is authorised to bind or contract KPMG International or any other member firm to any third party, just as KPMG International is not authorised to bind or contract any other member firm.

Scroll