Search
Contact
14.10.2021 | KPMG Law Insights

Advocate General at the ECJ: Minimum and maximum rates of the HOAI no longer applicable even in old cases between private parties

Advocate General at the ECJ: Minimum and maximum rates of the HOAI no longer applicable even in old cases between private parties

In his opinion of July 15, 2021, the Advocate General at the ECJ Maciej Szpunar emphasized for fee disputes under the validity of the HOAI 2013 that even in old cases between private parties the maximum and minimum rates of the HOAI 2013 no longer constitute mandatory price law. It is permissible to fall below the minimum rates and to exceed the maximum rates, provided that the parties agreed on a fee outside the price range of the HOAI 2013. This also applies to disputes between parties under private law, even if the relevant Services Directive (Directive of the European Parliament and of the Council of 12 December 2006 on services in the internal market – OJ 2006 L 376, p. 36) is not directly applicable in the horizontal relationship between private parties.

According to Advocate General Szpunar, the obligation of national courts to no longer apply the minimum and maximum rates in old cases as well results from the special character of the provisions of the Services Directive concretizing the freedom of establishment enshrined in the Treaty as well as from the required respect for the fundamental right of freedom of contract guaranteed in the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the EU.

The starting point for the proceedings before the ECJ was a question referred by the BGH as to how European law, in particular the Services Directive, was to be interpreted in the case of legal disputes between private parties under the then validity of the HOAI 2013. The BGH had to review a judgment of KG Berlin dated May 12, 2020 – 21 U 125/19. In its ruling, the KG had come to the conclusion that the Services Directive was not directly applicable to the detriment of the architect or engineer within a private legal relationship. Other higher regional courts (e.g. OLG Celle, judgment of 17.07.2019 – 14 U 188/18), on the other hand, had – now in line with the Advocate General’s opinion – left the minimum and maximum rates of HOAI 2013 unapplied due to the primacy of application of European law. KPMG Law had also reported on the state of opinion to date: https://kpmg-law.de/mandanten-information/hoai-mindestsaetze-europarechtswidrig-und-nun/

It remains to be seen how the ECJ will now rule on the question referred by the BGH, taking into account the Opinion. However, in practice, the Opinions are a fairly reliable indicator of European opinion. As a result of the ECJ’s decision, the BGH will then decide on the appeal against the judgment of the KG Berlin, taking into account the interpretation requirements from Europe.

For planner and engineer contracts concluded since January 1, 2021, the HOAI 2021 applies, which no longer provides for mandatory pricing law as a result of the ECJ ruling of July 4, 2019 (Case C-377/17): https://kpmg-law.de/newsservice/neue-hoai-2021-auswirkungen-auf-die-vertragsgestaltung-in-der-praxis/

Source: ECJ Press Release No. 140/2021 v. 15.07.2021

Explore #more

17.09.2025 | KPMG Law Insights

Circular economy: the construction sector needs a new legal framework

The construction sector is ready for the circular economy, but without a practicable legal framework, its commitment remains at a standstill. What is missing are…

15.09.2025 | KPMG Law Insights

Bundestag adopts new battery law

On September 11, 2025, the German Bundestag passed the Batterierecht-EU-Anpassungsgesetz (Battery Law Adaptation Act) to adapt German battery law to the EU Battery Regulation 2023/1542.…

15.09.2025 | In the media

Guest article in AssCompact: Embedded insurance: prospects, obligations, potentials

Embedded insurance is on the rise. Although it offers great potential for the insurance industry, it also poses challenges. KPMG Law expert Ulrich Keunecke explains…

12.09.2025 | Deal Notifications

KPMG Law advises managing partners of Deutsche Werkstätten Beteiligungs GmbH on sale to Ateliers de France

KPMG Law Rechtsanwaltsgesellschaft mbH (KPMG Law) advised the managing partner of Deutsche Werkstätten Beteiligungs GmbH, Mr. Fritz Straub, on the sale of a majority stake…

12.09.2025 | KPMG Law Insights, KPMG Law Insights

Key Facts about the new draft of the “Data Act

On February 23, 2022, the EU Commission presented the new draft of the so-called Data Act, the “Regulation on harmonized rules for fair access to…

09.09.2025 | Deal Notifications

KPMG Law and Tax advise Adiuva Capital GmbH with Fact Books on the sale of KONZMANN Group

KPMG Law Rechtsanwaltsgesellschaft mbH (KPMG Law) and KPMG AG Wirtschaftsprüfungsgesellschaft (KPMG) advised Adiuva Capital GmbH, a Hamburg-based private equity firm (Adiuva), in connection with the…

04.09.2025 | In the media

Guest article in Unternehmensjurist: Strategically transforming legal departments: A market overview

What are in-house teams at large companies concerned about when it comes to digital transformation? Which topics will be decisive in the coming years? The…

04.09.2025 | In the media

Guest article in the Unternehmensjurist: Successful change management in the HR department

The HR department plays a crucial role in the digital transformation. It is not only affected by change, but also shapes it. Between transformation, co-determination…

03.09.2025 | In the media

Guest article in the insurance industry: Embedded Insurance – More than just a new sales channel

The insurance industry is facing a paradigm shift. Traditional sales models are increasingly being supplemented by innovative approaches aimed at facilitating access to insurance policies…

03.09.2025 | KPMG Law Insights

Supply Chain Act: reporting obligation no longer applies, sanctions reduced

In the coalition agreement, the coalition partners agreed to abolish the Supply Chain Due Diligence Act (LkSG) as part of the implementation of the…

Contact

Dr. Torsten Göhlert

Partner

Galeriestraße 2
01067 Dresden

Tel.: +49 351 21294423
tgoehlert@kpmg-law.com

© 2024 KPMG Law Rechtsanwaltsgesellschaft mbH, associated with KPMG AG Wirtschaftsprüfungsgesellschaft, a public limited company under German law and a member of the global KPMG organisation of independent member firms affiliated with KPMG International Limited, a Private English Company Limited by Guarantee. All rights reserved. For more details on the structure of KPMG’s global organisation, please visit https://home.kpmg/governance.

 KPMG International does not provide services to clients. No member firm is authorised to bind or contract KPMG International or any other member firm to any third party, just as KPMG International is not authorised to bind or contract any other member firm.

Scroll